[USCC] Adverse Health Effects from Land Application of Biosolids

[John Cline]

Hello Caroline;

I cannot speak for Dr. Rubin, but for the information being "refuted"  
is not taken at face value as the paper being totally or even partly  
wrong depending on what is refuted.  What it does is open the door  
for further review by authors and reviewer(s) to present further  
research or evidence from each side concerning what is contested.

Cheers,

John Cline

On 1-Aug-06, at 6:59 PM, C. Snyder wrote:

>
>
> Dr. Rubin's last sentence in his 8/1/06  message,addressed to "Dave,"
> is soundly  refuted by a peer reviewed paper published in an
> international health journal and posted on www.sludgefacts.org as well
> as  by by a 2002 National Academy of Sciences  report which strongly
> urged that adverse health incidents, reported by sludge-exposed
> individuals, should be immediately investigated.
>
> Caroline Snyder
>
The Amaranth Group
     Amaranth and Associates
     Amaranth Co-operative Enterprises Ltd.
P.O. Box 444
1183 Hwy 358
Port Williams, Nova Scotia
B0P 1T0
Canada

Phone:   1-902-542-1430
Toll free: 1-866-673-1430
Fax:        1-902-482-5063

Visit our
Web site:  www.amaranth-recycle.ca
and or our fabricator's
www.nikdesign.com

Environmental Products, Education, Sustainable Development and
Consulting For A Conserver Society